Chart Of The Day: Netflix On A Supply-Demand Collision Course

 | Jun 12, 2019 15:01

Netflix (NASDAQ:NFLX) is up 37% YTD, significantly more than the NASDAQ’s less than 20% gain. And though the video streaming giant performed only slightly better than the rest of its FAANG cohort — Facebook Inc (NASDAQ:FB) +34%, Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) +25%, Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN) +26%, with the exception of Google (NASDAQ:GOOGL), up only 3% — Netflix’s recovery has become a benchmark for other companies.

But most of that dramatic recovery took place in January when the shares gained 27% after a strong Q4 earnings performance. After that, despite beating on both earnings and revenue in its April 16 Q1 report, the company’s weak guidance, compounded by the retirement of its CMO Kelly Bennett, left the stock without fuel. It's now 2.5% below its April 17 price.

Where to from here? Well, that’s cloudy.

There are those, such as RBC Capital analyst Mark Mahaney who believes the company has plateaued.

Sum Zero’s David Trainer sees the stock plummeting, citing its massive spending, and says subscriber growth should be disregarded unless the company is able to monetize its original content before competition eats into its market share. Half the world population signing on to the streaming service is required to justify its $350 per share valuation, which Trainer considers unrealistic.

We are inclined to agree with the latter outlook, based on the stock’s technicals.