By Danilo Masoni and Josephine Mason
MILAN/LONDON (Reuters) - With world equity markets set to call time on one of the longest bull markets in history, so-called 'value stocks' - wallflowers during the technology-led boom years - are suddenly back in fashion.
European value stocks, defined generally as firms whose fundamental worth is not reflected in their current share price, have outperformed growth stocks since early October as a dramatic sell-off swept across global equity markets unnerved by gradual end of a decade of easy money and rising trade tensions.
Companies that boast a faster pace of growth like the big U.S. tech names or Europe's luxury giants have been particularly favoured during the past decade of central bank largesse.
In contrast, the so-called value end of the market has become cheaper and cheaper, creating some opportunities.
Heading into 2019, investors in search of better returns are scanning stocks in beaten-down sectors like banks, builders, autos or telecoms, looking whether cash flows reflect poorly in shares prices or whether other valuation metrics have fallen below historical averages or are disconnected from the sector.
"After ten tough years, it's finally getting interesting," said Luiz Sauerbronn at U.S.-based Brandes Investment Partners.
"It has all been about technology and the high-flying growth stuff. In the last decade, value has only outperformed a couple of years in Europe, and October has been much better," added Sauerbronn, who helps manage nearly $28 billion.
In October when world stocks lost $7 trillion of market cap at one point, European value stocks <.MIEU0000VPEU> fell only 4.3 percent while the region's growth stocks <.MIEU0000GPEU> suffered their worst month since August 2015, down 6.5 percent.
The outperformance has continued so far in November.
Still from the 2009 lows, European growth has risen 150 percent, against a rise of 100 percent for value.
Last week, the Fed signalled it was still on course to increase rates next month.
"The growth stocks benefited tremendously from having zero rates. That's the status quo forever? I hope not, and I don't think it will be the case," Sauerbronn also said.
(Graphics of 'Value outperforms since early October' - https://tmsnrt.rs/2QsVqJw)
AVOIDING VALUE TRAPS
Buying value, however, is easier said than done, with the main challenge for investors being avoiding the so-called value traps, companies whose share price are cheap for a good reason.
"Value investing relies on a handful of stocks that go on to deliver high returns," Bernstein strategists said this month.
"Investing in the entire Value portfolio is not only impractical for most active investors, but is also subject to a massive return drag from the losers," they added.
Among their value picks they singled out several European companies in sectors such as mining, oil, airlines, construction and retail: Anglo American (L:AAL), Saipem (MI:SPMI), Lufthansa (DE:LHAG), LafargeHolcim (S:LHN), and Ahold-Delhaize (AS:AD).
Sauerbronn said that battered tobacco stocks also looked attractive now and that he was increasing exposure to the sector.
One feature of value stocks is that their valuations have generally fallen below historical averages, whereas growth stocks trade above in a gap that has been widening ever since 2008. Easy monetary policies and the growing success of passive investing has just amplified this spread.
Among miners, Anglo American, for example, is traded at around 0.5 times its cash flow, against a historical average of nearly 0.7 times, while peer Glencore (L:GLEN) is traded at 0.5 times vs more than 0.7 times.
In banks, Italian lender UniCredit (MI:CRDI) prices at around 0.5 times its book value, a 28 percent discount to euro zone banks, while French cement maker Lafarge Holcim is trading at its lowest PE multiple since 2011 and builder Saint Gobain (PA:SGOB) at its lowest in nearly a decade.
"Today there is very apparent value staring you in the face in certain parts of the market. Does that mean that those stocks go up tomorrow? Probably not," said Mark Breedon, who manages a 1.8 billion fund of global equities for Investec in Hong Kong.
"The question is getting the timing right. What you need is to start seeing those companies beating expectations or getting some technical momentum behind them as you never want to try catching a falling knife," he added.
According to Breedon, the most interesting opportunities can be found outside the main benchmarks, whose constituents have been lifted indiscriminately by the big flows provided by passive investing. Most stocks with a market cap above $1 billion are traded outside the dominant benchmarks, he said.
(Graphics of 'Growth vs Value over 10 years' - https://tmsnrt.rs/2QuNDuU)
START OF A TREND?
Even though it is too early to call the start of the trend in favour of value stocks, this market segment is increasingly becoming a hunting ground for investors.
Chris Hiorns, portfolio manager of the EdenTree Amity European Fund with just under 100 million pounds in assets under management and a long-time value bull, believes the recent shift in the market has been a move away from growth rather than a reallocation into value.
Hiorns still sees chances for further outperformance and has recently increased exposure to cheaply valued stocks such as tyremaker Michelin (PA:MICP), construction company Saint Gobain (PA:SGOB), staffing firm Randstad (AS:RAND), as well as banks ING (AS:INGA) and Santander (MC:SAN).
"The market is still very growth-oriented, but there's lots of capacity for value to outperform this year and into next year," he said. "Value bias is the place to be at the moment."